Constitutional Validity - The Legal Chamber

Domicile vs. Study: Supreme Court Explains Who Qualifies as a “Local” for Medical Seats

6Oct

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Domicile vs. Study: Supreme Court Explains Who Qualifies as a “Local” for Medical Seats

The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of Telangana's rules defining 'local candidates' for medical admissions. It ruled that the classification, based on consecutive years of study/residence within the state, is not arbitrary and falls within the legislative competence under Article 371D, Entry 25 of List III, and the relevant Presidential Order. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from challenges to the Telangana Medical & Dental Colleges Admission Rules, 2017, and their 2024 amendment, which defined 'local candidates' eligible for 85% state quota seats. The definition required candidates to have studied in educational institutions within the state for four consecutive years ending with the qualifying examination, or to have resided there for the same period if not...

Doctrine of Severability: Supreme Court Says Don’t Punish the Innocent for Administrative Lapses

20Sep

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Doctrine of Severability: Supreme Court Says Don’t Punish the Innocent for Administrative Lapses

The Supreme Court distinguished between irregular and illegal appointments, holding that procedural lapses not attributable to the appointees do not render appointments void if made against sanctioned posts by competent authority. The doctrine of severability applies to protect valid appointments from en masse cancellation, ensuring compliance with Articles 14 and 16. Natural justice mandates individual scrutiny before termination. Facts Of The Case: The appellants were initially appointed to Class-IV posts in the Jharkhand State Electricity Board (JSEB) between 2004–2006. Subsequently, they applied for and were selected for Class-III posts (Routine Clerk and Lower Division Assistant) through an internal recruitment process in 2009, pursuant to a standing order. Their appointments were f...

Beyond Impeachment: Supreme Court Validates Its Internal Mechanism for Judicial Misconduct

9Sep

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Beyond Impeachment: Supreme Court Validates Its Internal Mechanism for Judicial Misconduct

The Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the 'In-House Procedure' for investigating allegations of judicial misconduct. It ruled that the mechanism, which can recommend a judge's removal, is a valid exercise of the CJI's authority under the Judges (Protection) Act, 1985, and does not violate the constitutional scheme for impeachment. Facts Of The Case: In March 2025, a fire broke out in the store-room of a Delhi High Court judge's official bungalow while he was away. During efforts to douse the flames, officials discovered burnt currency notes on the premises. This discovery raised serious suspicions of misconduct, potentially violating the values outlined in the Restatement of Judicial Life. Consequently, the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court sought an explanation from the ...

Breaking Down the Supreme Court Judgment on DTH Services & Tax Dispute

7Jun

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Breaking Down the Supreme Court Judgment on DTH Services & Tax Dispute

The Supreme Court ruled that states have the legislative competence to levy entertainment tax on DTH services under Entry 62, List II (State List) of the Constitution, as the tax is on the "entertainment" aspect, not the broadcasting service. The Court upheld the "aspect doctrine", allowing simultaneous taxation by states (on entertainment) and the Centre (on broadcasting services under Entry 97, List I), provided the levies target distinct aspects of the same transaction. It rejected arguments of legislative overlap, emphasizing the pith and substance of state laws as valid exercises of taxing power. Facts Of The Case: The case involved multiple civil appeals and writ petitions challenging the constitutional validity of state laws imposing entertainment tax on Direct-to-Home (DTH) broad...