Tax Litigation - The Legal Chamber

Key Income Tax Ruling: Supreme Court Divided on Limitation Period Under Sections 144C & 153

11Sep

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Key Income Tax Ruling: Supreme Court Divided on Limitation Period Under Sections 144C & 153

The Supreme Court delivered a split verdict on the interplay between Sections 144C and 153 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The key legal question was whether the detailed procedure and timelines under Section 144C for eligible assessees operate within or in addition to the limitation period prescribed under Sections 153 for passing assessment orders. The divergence of opinion led to the matter being referred to a larger bench for final determination. Facts Of The Case: The case involved several foreign companies, including Shelf Drilling Ron Tappmeyer Ltd., engaged in oil exploration in India. For Assessment Years 2014-15 and 2018-19, the companies filed returns declaring losses. Their cases were selected for scrutiny, and the Assessing Officers passed draft assessment orders ...

Supreme Court Verdict on Cross-Border Taxation: Hyatt’s India Operations Fall Under PE, Income Taxable

18Aug

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Verdict on Cross-Border Taxation: Hyatt’s India Operations Fall Under PE, Income Taxable

The Supreme Court of India upheld the Delhi High Court's ruling that Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. had a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India under Article 5(1) of the India-UAE Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA). The Court emphasized that a fixed place of business PE exists if the enterprise has a right to use and control a physical location for its business activities, regardless of exclusive possession. The appellant's extensive control over hotel operations under the Strategic Oversight Services Agreement (SOSA) satisfied the "disposal test" and established a PE. Consequently, the income derived from these activities was deemed taxable in India under Article 7 of the DTAA. The appeals were dismissed, affirming the tax liability. Facts Of The Case: Hyatt Internation...

Supreme Court Rules Stem Cell Banking is Healthcare Service, Exempt from Tax

8Aug

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Rules Stem Cell Banking is Healthcare Service, Exempt from Tax

The Supreme Court held that stem cell banking services qualify as "Healthcare Services" under Notification No. 25/2012-ST, exempting them from service tax. The Court ruled that the extended limitation period under Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994, was unwarranted as there was no suppression or intent to evade tax. The subsequent Notification No. 4/2014-ST, though prospective, was deemed clarificatory. Penalties were set aside due to the appellant's bona fide belief and lack of deliberate contravention. The impugned order was quashed, and the refund of the deposited amount was ordered Facts Of The Case: The appellant, M/s. Stemcyte India Therapeutics Pvt. Ltd., engaged in the collection, processing, and storage of umbilical cord blood stem cells, claimed exemption from service tax unde...

No Double Benefits: Supreme Court Clarifies Double Deduction Rules Under Income Tax Act

3Jun

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

No Double Benefits: Supreme Court Clarifies Double Deduction Rules Under Income Tax Act

The Supreme Court ruled that Section 80-IA(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, bars double deductions on the same profits under both Sections 80-IA and 80-HHC. It held that while deductions can be computed separately under different provisions, the total deduction cannot exceed the eligible profits of the business. The Court upheld the Bombay High Court’s interpretation, clarifying that Section 80-IA(9) restricts the allowability—not computation—of deductions, ensuring taxpayers do not claim overlapping benefits under Chapter VI-A. Facts Of The Case: The case involved Shital Fibers Limited, which filed its income tax return for the Assessment Year 2002-03, declaring a taxable income of ₹46,99,293 and claiming deductions under Sections 80-HHC (export profits) and 80-IA (industrial undertaking...