Tag: High Court of Allahabad

Supreme Court Judgment: When a “Security Bond” is Actually a Mortgage: A Landmark Stamp Duty Ruling
23Dec By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Judgment: When a “Security Bond” is Actually a Mortgage: A Landmark Stamp Duty Ruling

In this judgment, the Supreme Court clarified the distinction between a mortgage deed and a security bond for stamp duty under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. The Court held that the substance of an instrument, not its nomenclature, determines its character. For Article 57 (security bond) to apply, a third-party surety distinct from the principal debtor must be involved. Since the deeds were executed by the principal debtors themselves to secure their own obligations, they were rightly classified as mortgage deeds chargeable under Article 40. Facts Of The Case: In Civil Appeal No. 7661 of 2014, M/s Godwin Construction Pvt. Ltd. executed a "Security Bond cum Mortgage Deed" on 19.12.2006 in favour of the Meerut Development Authority (MDA). This was done to secure performance of its oblig...
Read More
Public Trust Doctrine Violated in Hasty Land Allotment :Supreme Court Upholds Land Allotment Cancellation
14Jun By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Public Trust Doctrine Violated in Hasty Land Allotment :Supreme Court Upholds Land Allotment Cancellation

The Supreme Court upheld the cancellation of land allotment by UPSIDC due to the allottee's persistent payment defaults and failure to fulfill contractual obligations. The Court found that UPSIDC had followed the prescribed procedure for cancellation, including issuing multiple notices. The Court also annulled a subsequent allotment of the same land, emphasizing the need for transparent and non-discriminatory allocation of public resources in line with the Public Trust Doctrine Facts Of The Case: Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust (KNMT) applied in March 2003 to purchase 125 acres of land in Uttar Pradesh for floriculture. On September 18, 2003, Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation (UPSIDC) allotted the land, conditional upon certain terms, including a payment schedule. KNMT de...
Read More