Functional Disability - The Legal Chamber

Supreme Court Interprets New MV Act Law: Injury Claims Survive to Legal Heirs

25Nov

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Interprets New MV Act Law: Injury Claims Survive to Legal Heirs

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies that under Section 167(5) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, inserted by Act 32 of 2019, the right to claim compensation for personal injuries survives to the legal representatives of an injured person upon their death. This survival of the cause of action is applicable irrespective of whether the death has any nexus to the accident injuries. The Court thus overruled the contrary view taken in Bhagwati Bai. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from a motor accident in which the original claimant, Dhannalal, suffered injuries that resulted in 100% disability. He initially filed for compensation before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. Dissatisfied with the awarded amount, he appealed to the High Court, which enhanced the compensation. Still see...

Tribunal’s Income Assessment Upheld: Supreme Court Partially Allows Appeal in Injury Claim Case

22Nov

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Tribunal’s Income Assessment Upheld: Supreme Court Partially Allows Appeal in Injury Claim Case

The Supreme Court partially restored the Tribunal's compensation award, upholding the adopted monthly income and modifying attendant charges. It clarified that in the absence of a cross-appeal by the claimant, enhancement beyond the Tribunal's award or addition of future prospects cannot be claimed against the insurer's appeal. Facts Of The Case: On January 5, 2013, the appellant, Ramar, was standing by the side of the road when a rashly and negligently driven lorry hit him. The accident resulted in grievous injuries, leading to the amputation of his right leg from the thigh and a crush injury to his left leg, which paralyzed it. Medical evidence presented before the Tribunal, including the testimony of treating doctors and hospital records, proved the nature of the injuries and as...

Supreme Court Enhances Compensation: Income Tax Returns Must Be Considered for Accident Claims

11Oct

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Enhances Compensation: Income Tax Returns Must Be Considered for Accident Claims

The Supreme Court held that for motor accident compensation, the functional disability affecting earning capacity, not just medical disability, is determinative. Income tax returns must be reasonably considered unless proven fabricated. Just compensation includes actual medical expenses proven by vouchers and future medical needs, but future prospects are not awarded when the claimant can continue earning post-disability. Facts Of The Case: On April 9, 2007, the appellant, Anoop Maheshwari, was riding his motorbike when it was hit by a rashly and negligently driven truck. The accident resulted in Maheshwari suffering a severe injury, specifically a hemipelvectomy, which is the amputation of one leg along with a portion of the pelvic bone. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal established t...

Not Just Salaried: Supreme Court Rules Self-Employed Accident Victims Get Future Income Rise

8Sep

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Not Just Salaried: Supreme Court Rules Self-Employed Accident Victims Get Future Income Rise

The Supreme Court held that self-employed claimants are entitled to future prospects, affirming the principles in Santosh Devi and Pranay Sethi. It further ruled that uncontroverted medical evidence on disability must be accepted in its entirety, and the percentage of disability assessed by the treating doctor cannot be arbitrarily reduced by the Tribunal or High Court without reasoning. Facts Of The Case: On November 19, 2016, at approximately 6:00 a.m., the appellant, Lokesh B, a 38-year-old tailor, was driving his Omni car on the Peenya flyover in Bengaluru. His vehicle collided with a stationary lorry that was allegedly parked in the middle of the flyover without any indicators or reflective warnings. As a result of the collision, Lokesh sustained grievous injuries, including skull f...