framing of issues - The Legal Chamber

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies that a counter-claim under Order VIII Rule 6A of the CPC must be filed against the plaintiff, not solely against a co-defendant. Furthermore, while no specific time limit is prescribed, a counter-claim cannot be permitted after the framing of issues in the suit, as it defeats the purpose of speedy justice and procedural efficiency. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Rajul Manoj Shah, filed a suit in 2012 concerning a bungalow she jointly owned with her sister-in-law (defendant no.1). She sought a declaration that her sister-in-law had no right to transfer the property and to nullify an Agreement to Sell dated 21.10.2011 executed in favor of respondent no.1, Kiranbhai Patel (defendant no.2). After the sister-in-law passed away in ...

The Supreme Court reaffirmed that a plea of title by adverse possession cannot be raised for the first time at the appellate stage if it was not specifically pleaded in the plaint, framed as an issue, and proven during trial. Such a surprise claim prejudices the opposite party and is impermissible as a decision must be based on the case pleaded. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from a title suit filed in 1999 by the plaintiffs (Kishundeo Rout & Ors.) against the defendants (Govind Rao & Ors.). The plaintiffs sought a declaration that a 1997 sale deed executed by the original plaintiff, Sudama Devi, in favour of the defendants was bogus, inoperative, and fit for cancellation. They also prayed for confirmation of their possession and a permanent injunction again...

Tag: framing of issues

Supreme Court Rules: You Can’t Claim Adverse Possession for the First Time on Appeal