Tag: constitutional morality

A Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Directs States to Transform Beggars’ Homes from Prisons to Places of Care
Supreme Court

A Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Directs States to Transform Beggars’ Homes from Prisons to Places of Care

In a significant ruling, the Supreme Court issued comprehensive directives for all Beggars' Homes across India, mandating minimum standards for healthcare, sanitation, nutrition, and infrastructure. The judgment affirms that such institutions are a constitutional trust and that inhumane conditions violate the fundamental right to life with dignity under Article 21, requiring a shift from a punitive to a rehabilitative model. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from a Public Interest Litigation filed after news reports in May 2000 exposed a cholera and gastroenteritis outbreak at the Beggars’ Home in Lampur, Delhi, leading to multiple inmate deaths. The reports alleged that contaminated drinking water was the cause, a fact later confirmed by a magisterial inquiry which found faecal con...
Doctrine of Severability: Supreme Court Says Don’t Punish the Innocent for Administrative Lapses
Supreme Court

Doctrine of Severability: Supreme Court Says Don’t Punish the Innocent for Administrative Lapses

The Supreme Court distinguished between irregular and illegal appointments, holding that procedural lapses not attributable to the appointees do not render appointments void if made against sanctioned posts by competent authority. The doctrine of severability applies to protect valid appointments from en masse cancellation, ensuring compliance with Articles 14 and 16. Natural justice mandates individual scrutiny before termination. Facts Of The Case: The appellants were initially appointed to Class-IV posts in the Jharkhand State Electricity Board (JSEB) between 2004–2006. Subsequently, they applied for and were selected for Class-III posts (Routine Clerk and Lower Division Assistant) through an internal recruitment process in 2009, pursuant to a standing order. Their appointments were f...