Tag: Civil Suit

Supreme Court: Death of Appellant Before Hearing Renders Appellate Judgment Void
20Jan By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court: Death of Appellant Before Hearing Renders Appellate Judgment Void

The Supreme Court held that a decree passed in favor of deceased appellants, whose legal heirs were not substituted, is a nullity. Consequently, the original trial court decree revives and is executable, as a null appellate decree cannot supersede a valid prior decree. Facts Of The Case: The legal heirs of Arjunrao Thakre filed a civil suit challenging the re-allotment of his agricultural land to defendants 3 to 5. The trial court decreed the suit in 2006, declaring the plaintiffs as owners and the subsequent allotment illegal. Defendants 4 and 5 appealed. During the pendency of this first appeal, both appellants died—defendant 4 in 2006 and defendant 5 in 2010—but their legal heirs were never brought on record. Unaware of the deaths, the first appellate court heard and partl...
Read More
Supreme Court Revives Forgery Case: Fake Stamp Paper Probe Must Go On
19Jan By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Revives Forgery Case: Fake Stamp Paper Probe Must Go On

The Supreme Court held that a Magistrate's referral under Section 156(3) CrPC for police investigation is justified when a complaint discloses a cognizable offence and such a direction is conducive to justice. The High Court's orders quashing the referral were set aside, emphasizing that the police must be allowed to investigate prima facie allegations of forgery and fabrication of documents. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Sadiq B. Hanchinmani, filed a civil suit claiming ownership of a property via an oral gift from his father, challenging a registered sale deed in favour of accused No. 1, Veena. The suit was dismissed in 2013. During the pendency of his appeal (RFA No. 4095/2013) before the High Court, a status quo order on the property's title and possession was initially granted b...
Read More
Supreme Court Quashes FIR in Property Dispute, Says Mere Breach of Contract Isn’t Cheating
19Nov By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Quashes FIR in Property Dispute, Says Mere Breach of Contract Isn’t Cheating

The Supreme Court quashed criminal proceedings under Sections 406 and 420 IPC, holding that mere breach of contract does not constitute a criminal offence absent proof of dishonest intent at the inception. The allegations disclosed only a civil dispute, and continuing criminal prosecution amounted to an abuse of the process of the court. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Arshad Neyaz Khan, entered into an agreement to sell his property to the complainant, Md. Mustafa, in February 2013 for a consideration of Rs. 43,00,000, out of which an advance of Rs. 20,00,000 was paid. Nearly eight years later, in January 2021, the complainant filed a criminal complaint alleging that the appellant had failed to either transfer the property or refund the advance amount, accusing him of cheating, crimin...
Read More
Delayed Counter-Claim for Specific Performance Dismissed by Supreme Court
1Nov By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Delayed Counter-Claim for Specific Performance Dismissed by Supreme Court

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies that a counter-claim under Order VIII Rule 6A of the CPC must be filed against the plaintiff, not solely against a co-defendant. Furthermore, while no specific time limit is prescribed, a counter-claim cannot be permitted after the framing of issues in the suit, as it defeats the purpose of speedy justice and procedural efficiency. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Rajul Manoj Shah, filed a suit in 2012 concerning a bungalow she jointly owned with her sister-in-law (defendant no.1). She sought a declaration that her sister-in-law had no right to transfer the property and to nullify an Agreement to Sell dated 21.10.2011 executed in favor of respondent no.1, Kiranbhai Patel (defendant no.2). After the sister-in-law passed away in ...
Read More
Supreme Court Quashes FIR in Loan Case, Says Mere Default Doesn’t Make It a Crime
13Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Quashes FIR in Loan Case, Says Mere Default Doesn’t Make It a Crime

The Supreme Court held that a loan transaction creates a debtor-creditor relationship, and a mere breach of its terms does not automatically constitute criminal breach of trust under Section 405 IPC without evidence of dishonest intention. The Court clarified that such disputes, arising from commercial transactions, are primarily civil in nature and a preliminary inquiry is permissible before registering an FIR. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, a director of M/s Benlon India Ltd., availed three loans from the first respondent, Hero Fincorp, for purchasing machinery. While the first two loans were used for the intended purpose, a fire destroyed the plant shortly after the disbursement of the third loan. Consequently, this third loan was converted into an unsecured corporate loan. Benlon ...
Read More
Mandatory Rules for Ex-Parte Injunctions: A Key Reminder from the Supreme Court
13Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Mandatory Rules for Ex-Parte Injunctions: A Key Reminder from the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court emphasized that Order 39 Rule 3 CPC mandates recording reasons for granting ex parte injunction and strict compliance with procedural obligations by the applicant. Non-compliance warrants vacation of the ex parte order without adjudicating merits, ensuring the opposite party is not deprived of an early hearing. Facts Of The Case: The petitioner, Time City Infrastructure and Housing Limited, filed a civil suit claiming ownership and possession of certain land parcels in District Barabanki, based on an Agreement to Sell from 2015 and a subsequent Sale Deed from April 2025. The plaintiff alleged that peaceful physical possession was handed over in 2015 upon full payment, after which they developed the land with significant investment. The Civil Judge (Senior Division...
Read More
When a Society Becomes a “Trust”: Supreme Court’s Landmark Ruling on Mismanagement in Charitable NGOs
6Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

When a Society Becomes a “Trust”: Supreme Court’s Landmark Ruling on Mismanagement in Charitable NGOs

The Supreme Court ruled that a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, can be construed as a constructive trust under Section 92 CPC if it is created for public charitable purposes and its properties are held in a fiduciary capacity. This allows aggrieved parties to sue for breach of trust and seek remedies like a scheme for administration. Facts Of The Case: In 2005, Operation ASHA, a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, was established to provide healthcare services, particularly tuberculosis treatment, to underprivileged sections of society. A dispute arose in 2020 when its co-founder and CEO, Sandeep Ahuja (Respondent No. 3), terminated the services of another co-founder, Dr. Shelly Batra (Respondent No. 1), alleging misrepresentation ...
Read More
Supreme Court Shields Daughters-in-Law from Criminal Case Over Property Will
28Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Shields Daughters-in-Law from Criminal Case Over Property Will

The Supreme Court quashed criminal proceedings under Sections 419, 420, 467, 468, and 471 IPC, ruling the allegations did not prima facie constitute the alleged offences. Relying on Bhajan Lal, it held that criminal process cannot be used to settle civil disputes, as it amounts to an abuse of the court's process. Facts Of The Case: A testator, Shri Ram Baksh Dubey, executed an unregistered will in 1993 bequeathing his property to his four daughters-in-law, apprehensive that his third son, Ashish Kumar, would squander the estate. After the testator’s death in 1994, Ashish Kumar sold his purported share to the complainant, Balram, via a registered sale deed. The daughters-in-law, unaware of this sale, successfully obtained a mutation order in their favor based on the will. When Balram inte...
Read More