Tag: Wrongful gain

Supreme Court: Amicable Settlement Leads to Full Quashing of FIR, Including Dacoity Charge
4Feb By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court: Amicable Settlement Leads to Full Quashing of FIR, Including Dacoity Charge

The Supreme Court quashed an FIR for dacoity (BNS S. 310(2)/IPC S. 395) as the alleged acts lacked dishonest intention for theft/robbery—a prerequisite for dacoity. The Court held that subsequent full restitution and amicable settlement with the complainant negated the core criminal intent, rendering the entire prosecution unsustainable. Facts Of The Case: The complainant, a school clerk, alleged that on October 4, 2024, six to seven unknown persons entered P.G. Public School in Nandurbar. They demanded specific Engineering and B.A.M.S. files, assaulted and intimidated staff, and forcibly took a cheque book, blank letterheads, stamps, cash (Rs. 1,50,000), and a computer. The accused were allegedly searching for institutional documents, and the taking of property was incidental. Subsequen...
Read More
Supreme Court Quashes Cheating Case: Fake Fire NOC Not Needed for School Building
27Oct By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Quashes Cheating Case: Fake Fire NOC Not Needed for School Building

The Supreme Court quashed the proceedings under Section 420 IPC, holding that the essential ingredients of cheating were not made out. As the institution's building height was below 15 metres, a Fire NOC was not legally required for affiliation; thus, the alleged false representation could not have induced the authorities to act, negating dishonest intention. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, representing JVRR Education Society, was implicated in a criminal case for allegedly using a forged No-Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Fire Department to obtain recognition and renewal of affiliation for its educational institution. The First Information Report was registered based on a complaint from the District Fire Officer, leading to a chargesheet under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code...
Read More
Supreme Court Quashes FIR in Loan Case, Says Mere Default Doesn’t Make It a Crime
13Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Quashes FIR in Loan Case, Says Mere Default Doesn’t Make It a Crime

The Supreme Court held that a loan transaction creates a debtor-creditor relationship, and a mere breach of its terms does not automatically constitute criminal breach of trust under Section 405 IPC without evidence of dishonest intention. The Court clarified that such disputes, arising from commercial transactions, are primarily civil in nature and a preliminary inquiry is permissible before registering an FIR. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, a director of M/s Benlon India Ltd., availed three loans from the first respondent, Hero Fincorp, for purchasing machinery. While the first two loans were used for the intended purpose, a fire destroyed the plant shortly after the disbursement of the third loan. Consequently, this third loan was converted into an unsecured corporate loan. Benlon ...
Read More
CBI vs. Accused: Supreme Court Rules on Discharge in Cotton MSP Scam Case
7Jun By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

CBI vs. Accused: Supreme Court Rules on Discharge in Cotton MSP Scam Case

The Supreme Court held that the trial court and High Court erred in discharging the accused under Section 239 CrPC by relying on defence-produced documents (CCI’s exoneration letter) at the pre-trial stage. Reiterating Debendra Nath Padhi, it ruled that only prosecution material under Section 173 CrPC can be considered for discharge, not extraneous evidence. The Court emphasized that discharge requires examining whether the chargesheet discloses a prima facie case, without evaluating defence merits. The matter was remanded for fresh consideration under Section 239 CrPC, barring reliance on non-prosecution documents. Facts Of The Case: The case involves a criminal conspiracy where Rayapati Subba Rao (A-1), a Cotton Purchase Officer (CPO) of Cotton Corporation of India (CCI), Guntur, alleg...
Read More