Tag: Surrender Order

Supreme Court’s Big Ruling: Criminal History Matters in Bail for Heinous Crimes
8Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court’s Big Ruling: Criminal History Matters in Bail for Heinous Crimes

The Supreme Court overturned a bail order, ruling that the High Court failed to apply correct legal principles under Section 389 CrPC for suspending a sentence. It emphasized that post-conviction bail in heinous offences requires a palpable prima facie case for acquittal, not a re-appreciation of evidence or conjectural reasoning. Facts Of The Case: In a case originating from Rajasthan, the prosecutrix, a 14-year-old girl, testified that on June 13, 2023, Respondent No. 2 accosted her at gunpoint while she was defecating in a field. He covered her mouth, forcibly took her to a nearby abandoned house, and raped her. She immediately reported the incident to her family, and her father filed an FIR. The Trial Court convicted Respondent No. 2 under the POCSO Act and sentenced him to 20 years ...
Read More
Supreme Court Upholds Life Sentence: Daughter’s Testimony Convicts Father in Wife’s Murder
26Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Upholds Life Sentence: Daughter’s Testimony Convicts Father in Wife’s Murder

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction under Section 302 IPC, affirming the reliability of a child witness. It ruled that the accused's mere denial under Section 313 CrPC was insufficient to discharge his burden under Section 106 of the Evidence Act to explain the circumstances of his wife's death within their home. Facts Of The Case: The case involved the murder of Smt. Ranjana by her husband, the accused-appellant Manohar Keshavora Khandate, within their home in Amravati. The prosecution's case rested primarily on the eyewitness account of their nine-year-old daughter (PW-3). She testified that on the night of the incident, she was sleeping beside her mother when she was awakened by a commotion. She found her father sitting nearby her mother, whose body was covered with a chaddar. The...
Read More
Supreme Court: Jail Overcrowding Can’t Be a Ground for Granting Bail in Heinous Crimes
25Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court: Jail Overcrowding Can’t Be a Ground for Granting Bail in Heinous Crimes

The Supreme Court held that the High Court erred in granting bail without properly considering the absence of "new circumstances" as mandated by the Court's earlier judgment cancelling bail. The impugned order lacked cogent reasoning, relied on irrelevant factors like jail overcrowding, and failed to accord due deference to the Supreme Court's previous decision, warranting its quashing. Facts Of The Case: The case involves an appeal by the informant, Ajwar, against an order of the Allahabad High Court granting bail to the accused, Waseem. Waseem was charged under various sections of the IPC, including Section 302 (murder). His bail was initially granted by the High Court in 2022 but was cancelled by the Supreme Court. A subsequent grant of bail by the High Court was again cancelled by th...
Read More
“Masterminds Can’t Claim Parity with Minor Accused”: Supreme Court Overrules Bail Order under 302 IPC
17May By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

“Masterminds Can’t Claim Parity with Minor Accused”: Supreme Court Overrules Bail Order under 302 IPC

The Supreme Court ruled that bail parity cannot be mechanically applied when material distinctions exist between accused persons. It held that alleged conspirators/masterminds of a serious crime (Section 302 IPC) cannot claim bail parity with minor co-accused, especially when evidence suggests their active role in hiring a contract killer. The Court emphasized that bail decisions must consider the gravity of allegations, evidentiary role of each accused, and potential witness intimidation, rather than granting parity as a blanket rule. The judgment clarified that "parity" under Section 439 CrPC requires comparable roles, not mere similarity of charges. Facts Of The Case: The case involves a brutal shooting during a marriage procession in Rajasthan on November 28, 2023. The prosecution al...
Read More