Tag: state action

Supreme Court Balances Fairness & Flexibility in Govt. Contracts, Upholds Cancellation of LoI in Himachal Case
10Feb By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Balances Fairness & Flexibility in Govt. Contracts, Upholds Cancellation of LoI in Himachal Case

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies that a Letter of Intent is a conditional, non-binding precursor to a contract, creating no vested rights until stipulated prerequisites are fulfilled. The Court held that the State's cancellation of such an LoI is valid if based on genuine grounds of non-compliance and public interest, and is not arbitrary per se. Facts Of The Case: The State of Himachal Pradesh initiated a tender process to upgrade its Public Distribution System with biometric and IRIS-enabled ePOS devices. After four rounds of tendering, M/s OASYS Cybermatics Pvt. Ltd. emerged as the sole technically qualified bidder and was issued a Letter of Intent (LoI) in September 2022. The LoI was conditional, requiring successful compatibility testing, live demonstrations, an...
Read More
Supreme Court Sets Aside Mining Tender: “Previous Year” Means Year Before Bid
21Jan By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Sets Aside Mining Tender: “Previous Year” Means Year Before Bid

The Supreme Court emphasized that judicial review in tender matters ensures fairness and non-arbitrariness under Article 14. It held that misinterpretation of a tender condition, which wrongly excludes the highest bidder and deprives the state of revenue, vitiates the decision-making process. The court underscored the state's duty to maximize public value in natural resource auctions. Facts Of The Case: The case involved a public auction for a five-year sand quarry lease in Odisha. The appellant, M/s Shanti Construction Pvt. Ltd., was the highest bidder but its bid was rejected by the Tender Committee for allegedly failing to comply with Rule 27(4)(iv) of the Odisha Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2016. The rule required submission of an Income Tax Return for the "previous Financial Year...
Read More