Model Litigant?: Supreme Court Slams State Agency for Derailing 3-Year Arbitration Process
The Supreme Court held that an arbitration agreement survives even if the unilateral appointment mechanism is invalid; such offending portions are severable. Courts cannot review Section 11 orders absent patent error. Joint Section 29A extensions constitute waiver under Section 4 but cannot cure Section 12(5) ineligibility, which requires express post-dispute written waiver. Non-speaking SLP dismissal does not affirm underlying judgment
Facts Of The Case:
The dispute originated from a contract dated 04.03.2014 awarded by Respondent No. 1, Bihar Rajya Pul Nirman Nigam Limited, to the appellant, Hindustan Construction Company Limited, for construction of a bridge over the River Sone in Bihar. The contract contained Clause 25 providing for arbitration. The appellant had previously inv...