Section 323 IPC - The Legal Chamber

In a significant ruling, the Supreme Court quashed criminal proceedings under Sections 323, 498A IPC and the Dowry Act against a brother-in-law, emphasizing that vague and omnibus allegations without specific instances of cruelty or harassment do not constitute a prima facie case. The Court reiterated the legal principles from State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, cautioning against the misuse of criminal provisions in matrimonial disputes and underscoring the necessity for concrete allegations to initiate prosecution. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from an FIR lodged by Smt. Jyoti Garg (Respondent No. 2) against her husband, mother-in-law, and her brother-in-law, Shobhit Kumar Mittal (the Appellant). The complainant alleged that within days of her marriage in 2014, she was harassed fo...

The Supreme Court acquitted the appellant of charges under Section 8(2) of the Goa Children's Act, 2003, ruling that a single, incidental act of hitting a child with a school bag during a scuffle, absent evidence of deliberate cruelty or sustained maltreatment, does not meet the legal definition of "child abuse." The Court also set aside the conviction under Section 504 IPC, finding no intent to provoke a breach of peace. However, convictions under Sections 323 and 352 IPC were upheld, with the appellant granted probation. Facts Of The Case: On February 1, 2013, an incident occurred on the premises of St. Ann’s School in Goa involving the appellant, Santosh Khajnekar. He was alleged to have hit a child with a school bag belonging to his own son during a sudden altercation. The Fi...

Tag: Section 323 IPC

Allegations Must Be Specific: Supreme Court’s Warning Against Misuse of Dowry Law

Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Says Not Every Act Against a Child is “Abuse”