property litigation - The Legal Chamber

The Supreme Court held that In disputes over landlord-tenant relationships, the Supreme Court clarified that under the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999, the production of rent receipts signed by the landlord constitutes prima facie evidence of the jural relationship. Once this initial burden is discharged, the Rent Controller is justified in proceeding with the eviction case without delving into title disputes, which are beyond its scope. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, H.S. Puttashankara, filed an eviction petition against the respondent, Yashodamma, under the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999, concerning a property in Bengaluru. The appellant claimed to be the landlord, asserting that the property originally belonged to his great-grandfather and devolved to him through a release deed from other legal...

The Supreme Court partially allowed the appeal, modifying the High Court's order by reducing the appellant's liability to ₹15 lakhs as full and final settlement of the decree. The Court exercised its discretionary power under Article 142 to ensure complete justice, considering prolonged litigation, and clarified that the order was fact-specific and not a precedent. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from a money recovery suit filed by the respondent, V. Sudarsanan, against the original defendants for ₹79,69,544/- with 9% interest on a principal loan of ₹58,50,000/- secured by a mortgage. During the pendency of the suit, the appellant, Umedraj Jain, purchased the mortgaged property from the defendants and attempted to implead himself in the proceedings, but his application was dismiss...

Tag: property litigation

Proof of Tenancy: Supreme Court’s Key Ruling on Rent Receipts and Title Disputes

Supreme Court Landmark Settlement : Order Caps Pending Debt at ₹15 Lakhs in Mortgage Case