Legal Representatives - The Legal Chamber

Supreme Court: Delayed Payment Not Always Contempt, But Bank Must Pay for Protracted Litigation

20Sep

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court: Delayed Payment Not Always Contempt, But Bank Must Pay for Protracted Litigation

The Supreme Court declined to initiate contempt proceedings, finding the delayed payment of dues, while a violation, was not wilful. It reinforced that contempt jurisdiction cannot be used to adjudicate new claims like pension, which were not part of the original decree. The Court, however, awarded compensatory costs for the protracted litigation. Facts Of The Case: A.K. Jayaprakash, a manager at Nedungadi Bank Ltd., was dismissed from service in 1985 on grounds of alleged irregularities in sanctioning loans and delays in reporting. He challenged this dismissal under the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishment Act, 1947. The Deputy Commissioner of Labour initially set aside the dismissal and ordered his reinstatement. This decision was repeatedly challenged by the Bank, first in the Madras Hi...

Supreme Court Slams “Ad-hocism”: Orders Regularization of Employees After 30+ Years of Service

19Sep

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Slams “Ad-hocism”: Orders Regularization of Employees After 30+ Years of Service

This Supreme Court judgment reaffirms that the State, as a constitutional employer, cannot deny regularization of perennial work performed by long-serving ad hoc employees. Arbitrary refusals to sanction posts based on financial constraints violate Articles 14, 16, and 21. The Court mandated the creation of supernumerary posts for regularization, emphasizing that outsourcing cannot justify exploitation or circumvent the duty to provide fair and secure employment. Facts Of The Case: The appellants were engaged as daily wage employees (Class-III Driver and Class-IV Peons/Attendants) by the U.P. Higher Education Services Commission between 1989 and 1992. They performed regular, perennial duties essential to the Commission's functioning. In 1991, the Commission itself resolved to create four...

Land Sale Void If Society’s Charge Not Cleared: Supreme Court Explains Legal Consequence

14Jun

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Land Sale Void If Society’s Charge Not Cleared: Supreme Court Explains Legal Consequence

The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal, affirming that a plaintiff cannot benefit from their own wrong. The Court held that an alienation of charged property, even if voidable, can only be challenged by the aggrieved society, not the member-loanee who committed the breach. Subsequent release of the charge validated the sale, and the reconveyance deed was deemed invalid due to lack of stamp paper, registration, and crucial terms. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from Special Civil Suit No. 49/1973, filed by the original plaintiff, Machhindranath, seeking possession and reconveyance of ancestral agricultural land, Survey No. 30, admeasuring 15 Acres and 17 Guntha, located in Village Kendal Bk., Taluka Rahuri, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra. The plaintiff had obtained a loan from Kendal Bk....

Supreme Court Rejects Salary Cut: Widow, Kids, and Parents Get Full Compensation in Fatal Truck Accident Case”

21May

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Rejects Salary Cut: Widow, Kids, and Parents Get Full Compensation in Fatal Truck Accident Case”

The Supreme Court restored the Tribunal’s compensation award for the family of a deceased truck driver, rejecting the High Court’s reduction of income from ₹10,000 to ₹4,076 per month. Citing Ramachandrappa v. Royal Sundaram Alliance, it upheld ₹10,000 as justified wages for 2014. The Court also affirmed loss of consortium for children and parents under Somwati v. New India Assurance, stressing equitable apportionment. The judgment reinforces fair compensation principles in motor accident claims, emphasizing statutory and precedential rights of dependents. Facts Of The Case: The case involved a fatal motor accident where a truck driver, aged 28, was hit and killed by another negligently driven truck while he was boarding his parked vehicle. The deceased’s legal representatives—his wido...