Tag: Insurance Claim Dispute

Supreme Court’s Key Ruling :Notional Income of an Engineering Student Should Be Higher
Supreme Court

Supreme Court’s Key Ruling :Notional Income of an Engineering Student Should Be Higher

The Supreme Court modified the contributory negligence apportionment to 20% on the claimant, 50% on the car driver, and 30% on the bus driver. It enhanced compensation by revising the notional income calculation for an engineering student and reinstated attendant charges, emphasizing just compensation for 100% disability. Facts Of The Case: On January 7, 2017, the appellant, a 20-year-old engineering student, was riding a motorcycle with a friend on the pillion. A car ahead, driven by respondent no. 2, suddenly applied its brakes on the highway because the driver's pregnant wife felt a vomiting sensation. This caused the appellant to collide with the rear of the car and fall onto the road. Subsequently, a bus, insured by respondent no. 1, which was coming from behind, ran over the appell...
Homeowner Wins 7-Year Battle: Supreme Court Orders Insurer to Pay for Rain-Flooded Basement
Supreme Court

Homeowner Wins 7-Year Battle: Supreme Court Orders Insurer to Pay for Rain-Flooded Basement

The Supreme Court held that heavy rainfall causing sudden basement flooding constitutes a covered "flood/inundation" peril under standard insurance policies, rejecting the insurer’s "seepage" exclusion. It ruled that insurers cannot arbitrarily disregard initial survey reports confirming flood damage in favor of belated contradictory assessments. The Court remanded the matter to NCDRC solely for compensation quantification under the policy terms, emphasizing objective claim evaluation aligned with contractual obligations. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Gopal Dikshit, owned a property at 50, Ishwar Nagar, Mathura Road, New Delhi, insured under a ₹1.5 crore House Holder Policy (No. 2219042615P115431073) by United India Insurance for the period March 13, 2016, to March 12, 20...