Supreme Court Ruling: Port Tariffs Must Be Set By Experts, Not Arbitrators
The Supreme Court held that tariff fixation for port facilities is a technical and expert-driven function, best adjudicated by specialized bodies like TAMP. It emphasized that contractual agreements cannot override statutory tariff-setting mechanisms under the Major Port Authorities Act, 2021. The Court remanded the matter to TAMP for fresh determination, underscoring the need for expert appraisal of tariff revisions and compliance with natural justice.
Facts Of The Case:
A bilateral agreement was executed in 1985 between Paradip Port Trust (now Authority) and Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. (PPL), then a public sector unit, for the exclusive use of a captive fertilizer berth. The agreement stipulated a tariff schedule, with a clause for future mutual enhancement. In 1993, the Port unilaterally...
