Tag: Hindu Marriage Act

Marriage Dead: Supreme Court Dissolves Union, Quashes 498A Case in Landmark Irretrievable Breakdown Ruling
6Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Marriage Dead: Supreme Court Dissolves Union, Quashes 498A Case in Landmark Irretrievable Breakdown Ruling

The Supreme Court, invoking its extraordinary power under Article 142 of the Constitution, dissolved the marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown. It quashed the pending criminal proceedings under Section 498-A IPC, finding the allegations to be vague and arising from marital discord, while upholding the terms of a settlement agreement for a clean break. Facts Of The Case: The marriage between Anurag Goel (appellant-husband) and the second respondent (wife) took place on July 25, 2015, following prior divorces for both. After approximately one year and nine months of conjugal life, the relationship soured. The husband alleged constant harassment, leading him to abandon the matrimonial home—a Mumbai apartment he owned—in April 2017 to move to Faridabad with his autistic child fro...
Read More
Supreme Court Ends Bitter Divorce Battle: Key Takeaways on Custody & Settlement
16Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Ends Bitter Divorce Battle: Key Takeaways on Custody & Settlement

The Supreme Court, invoking Article 142, dissolved the marriage between Shivangi Bansal and Sahib Bansal, quashing all pending civil/criminal cases between them and their families. The wife retained custody of their daughter, while the husband secured visitation rights. Mutual undertakings barred future litigation, and an unconditional apology was mandated. Property transfer and police protection were also ordered, ensuring a conclusive settlement. Facts Of The Case: The case involves Shivangi Bansal (wife) and Sahib Bansal (husband), who married in December 2015 and had a daughter in 2016. After marital discord, they separated in October 2018, leading to multiple legal battles across courts in Delhi and Uttar Pradesh. The wife filed cases under Sections 498A, 406 IPC, and the Domestic V...
Read More
Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Restores Mother’s Custody Based on Psychological Reports
11Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Restores Mother’s Custody Based on Psychological Reports

The Supreme Court exercised its review jurisdiction under Article 137 of the Constitution, emphasizing the limited scope of review and the paramount consideration of the child's welfare in custody matters. The Court recalled its earlier order, restoring custody to the mother while granting visitation rights to the father, citing the child's mental health and stability as decisive factors. The judgment reaffirmed that custody orders are interlocutory and subject to modification based on the child's evolving best interests, aligning with the doctrine of parens patriae. The Court underscored the necessity of a stable environment for the child's holistic development and cautioned against abrupt changes in custody arrangements. Facts Of The Case: The case involves a custody dispute between Ne...
Read More
Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Dissolves Marriage Under Article 142 for Unhappy Couple
11Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Landmark Ruling: Supreme Court Dissolves Marriage Under Article 142 for Unhappy Couple

The Supreme Court granted divorce under Article 142 on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, citing 16 years of separation and failed reconciliation. It upheld the husband’s acquittal in a false cruelty case (IPC 498A) and enhanced maintenance to ₹15,000/month for the wife and child, prioritizing dignity over a defunct marital bond. Facts Of The Case: The marriage between Pradeep Bhardwaj (appellant-husband) and Priya (respondent-wife) was solemnized on 7 May 2008 in Delhi under Hindu rites. A son was born in 2009, who remained in the wife’s custody. The couple separated in October 2009, just over a year after marriage, and had been living apart for 16 years by the time of the Supreme Court’s judgment. The husband filed for divorce in 2010 under Section 13(1)(a) of the Hindu...
Read More
Supreme Court Invokes Article 142 : Dissolves Marriage After 12+ Years of Separation “Irretrievable Breakdown”
7May By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Invokes Article 142 : Dissolves Marriage After 12+ Years of Separation “Irretrievable Breakdown”

The Supreme Court, invoking Article 142 of the Constitution, dissolved the marriage on grounds of irretrievable breakdown, despite the absence of statutory provisions under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. Relying on precedents like Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan, the Court emphasized prolonged separation (12+ years) and failed reconciliation attempts as justification, prioritizing an end to protracted litigation over traditional fault-based grounds. No alimony was awarded as the wife waived her claim. Facts Of The Case: The case involves a matrimonial dispute between Kumari Rekha (appellant-wife) and Shambhu Saran Paswan (respondent-husband), whose marriage was solemnized on 24th April 1999. They had a daughter born on 7th June 2001, but the couple had been living separately for over ...
Read More