Tag: execution of will

Tenant Can’t Deny Landlord’s Title, Rules Supreme Court in Key Eviction Case
28Oct By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Tenant Can’t Deny Landlord’s Title, Rules Supreme Court in Key Eviction Case

The Supreme Court held that in an eviction suit, strict proof of ownership is not required. A tenant cannot deny the landlord's title under whom they entered possession. The Will bequeathing the property, especially when probated, confers sufficient legal sanctity to maintain the eviction proceedings. The bona fide need of the landlord was also upheld. Facts Of The Case: The dispute involves a shop room tenancy initiated in 1953 by Ramji Das, the appellant's father-in-law, with the father of the respondents. Upon Ramji Das's death in 1999, a Will bequeathed the shop to the appellant, Jyoti Sharma. She subsequently filed a suit for eviction on grounds of bona fide need, seeking to expand her husband's adjacent sweets business, and for recovery of rent arrears from January 2000. Th...
Read More
Supreme Court : Wife as Attesting Witness Does Not Invalidate a Will
9Oct By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court : Wife as Attesting Witness Does Not Invalidate a Will

The Supreme Court held that the High Court erred in framing an additional substantial question of law under Section 100(5) CPC without foundational pleadings, issues, or recorded reasons. A will, once duly executed and proved, must be given effect to, and succession cannot be reopened on a new legal case at the second appeal stage. The testamentary disposition was upheld. Facts Of The Case: The case concerns a dispute over the estate of C.R. Pius and Philomina Pius. The couple executed a registered joint will in 2003, bequeathing their properties to their son, C.P. Francis (the Appellant), subject to the condition that he pay specific monetary sums to his siblings. After the parents' deaths, the other children (Respondents) filed a suit for partition, claiming their parents died intestat...
Read More