Tag: executing court

Supreme Court: Death of Appellant Before Hearing Renders Appellate Judgment Void
20Jan By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court: Death of Appellant Before Hearing Renders Appellate Judgment Void

The Supreme Court held that a decree passed in favor of deceased appellants, whose legal heirs were not substituted, is a nullity. Consequently, the original trial court decree revives and is executable, as a null appellate decree cannot supersede a valid prior decree. Facts Of The Case: The legal heirs of Arjunrao Thakre filed a civil suit challenging the re-allotment of his agricultural land to defendants 3 to 5. The trial court decreed the suit in 2006, declaring the plaintiffs as owners and the subsequent allotment illegal. Defendants 4 and 5 appealed. During the pendency of this first appeal, both appellants died—defendant 4 in 2006 and defendant 5 in 2010—but their legal heirs were never brought on record. Unaware of the deaths, the first appellate court heard and partl...
Read More
Society Cannot Evade Decree by Raising Unauthorized Constructions, Rules Supreme Court
24Dec By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Society Cannot Evade Decree by Raising Unauthorized Constructions, Rules Supreme Court

The Supreme Court upheld the enforceability of a cooperative court's decree for specific performance, ruling that subsequent unauthorized constructions and unapproved plot mergers do not render a decree inexecutable. The Court directed the removal of obstructing structures to facilitate the allotment and delivery of vacant possession to the decree-holder, affirming the executability of the award. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Southern Nagpur Co-operative Society Limited, was directed by the Cooperative Court in a 2000 award to allot Plot No. 5A to its member, respondent Ganpati Yadavrao Kumbhare, a decree upheld in subsequent appeals. During execution proceedings, the appellant society objected, claiming the plot had lost its identity as it was merged with adjoining Plots 4 and 4A in...
Read More
Specific Performance Suit Fails: Supreme Court Explains Why Buyer Must Vacate Despite Long Possession
4Dec By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Specific Performance Suit Fails: Supreme Court Explains Why Buyer Must Vacate Despite Long Possession

The Supreme Court affirmed the executability of a warrant of possession, ruling that a party who receives substantial monetary compensation in lieu of specific performance cannot retain possession of the property. The Court held that equity prevents unjust enrichment and that execution proceedings exist to enforce judgments, not to facilitate windfalls for unscrupulous litigants. Facts Of The Case: On 12.06.1989, the defendants agreed to sell a property to the plaintiff for ₹14,50,000, with ₹25,000 paid as earnest money. Possession of the vacant ground floor was handed over to the plaintiff. In 1990, the plaintiff first filed and withdrew a suit for permanent injunction. Subsequently, in June 1990, the plaintiff filed a suit for specific performance, which was decreed by the Trial Court ...
Read More
Supreme Court Allows Execution Petition: No Time Limit for Enforcing Permanent Injunctions
26May By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Allows Execution Petition: No Time Limit for Enforcing Permanent Injunctions

The Supreme Court ruled that a decree of permanent injunction creates a perpetual right enforceable at any time against future breaches, clarifying that satisfaction recorded in one execution petition doesn't bar subsequent petitions under Section 47 CPC for fresh violations. It held that Article 136 of the Limitation Act imposes no time limit for enforcing perpetual injunctions, rejecting the erroneous application of res judicata by lower courts. The judgment emphasizes that each breach of injunction constitutes a fresh cause of action, requiring executing courts to examine subsequent execution petitions on merits regardless of prior disposals. The Court distinguished between temporary and permanent injunctions while underscoring the continuing nature of injunctive relief. Facts Of The C...
Read More