Environmental degradation - The Legal Chamber

The Supreme Court, overturning a High Court order, ruled that restoring a demolished lake to its original state was not feasible given the passage of time and the establishment of a public park. The Court balanced environmental conservation with public welfare, emphasizing that the public trust doctrine must consider practical realities. It directed the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) to maintain the park, explore alternative water bodies, and restore other deteriorated water bodies. Facts Of The Case: The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) undertook a redevelopment project on a plot (CTS No. 417) at Khajuria Tank Road, Kandivali (West), Mumbai, for a theme park. This project allegedly led to the obliteration of a lake that had existed at the premises for app...

The Supreme Court ruled that penalties under Section 26 of the NGT Act, 2010 cannot be imposed without proving willful disobedience by the accused. It held that the Mayor, not being a party to the original proceedings and lacking executive authority over waste management, could not be penalized for violations. However, the Municipal Corporation's fine for environmental damage was upheld. The Court emphasized that strict construction of penal provisions is necessary and accepted the Mayor's unconditional apology for remarks against the NGT, setting aside his punishment while clarifying the limits of liability under environmental laws Facts Of The Case: Rayons-Enlighting Humanity, Invertis University, and residents of Village Razau Paraspur, Bareilly, filed applications with the Na...

Tag: Environmental degradation

Balancing Ecology & Development : Supreme Court’s Verdict on Mumbai’s Khajuria Lake Case

Section 26 NGT Act Strictly Applied: Supreme Court Clarifies Penal Liability in Environmental Violations