Enforceability - The Legal Chamber

The Supreme Court held that a decree passed in favor of deceased appellants, whose legal heirs were not substituted, is a nullity. Consequently, the original trial court decree revives and is executable, as a null appellate decree cannot supersede a valid prior decree. Facts Of The Case: The legal heirs of Arjunrao Thakre filed a civil suit challenging the re-allotment of his agricultural land to defendants 3 to 5. The trial court decreed the suit in 2006, declaring the plaintiffs as owners and the subsequent allotment illegal. Defendants 4 and 5 appealed. During the pendency of this first appeal, both appellants died—defendant 4 in 2006 and defendant 5 in 2010—but their legal heirs were never brought on record. Unaware of the deaths, the first appellate court heard and partl...

This Supreme Court judgment reaffirms that a valid arbitration agreement can be constituted through conduct and correspondence, without a signed contract. The Supreme Court held that if parties have demonstrably acted upon the terms of an unsigned agreement, they are bound by its arbitration clause, and a referral court need only conduct a prima facie review of the agreement's existence. Facts Of The Case: The dispute arose from a proposed contract for the sale of 6,000 metric tons of zinc metal between Glencore International AG (Appellant) and Shree Ganesh Metals (Respondent No.1). The terms were negotiated via email, and Glencore sent a formal contract (No. 061-16-12115-S) incorporating an arbitration clause, which it signed. The Respondent, however, never signed this document. Despite...

Tag: Enforceability

Supreme Court: Death of Appellant Before Hearing Renders Appellate Judgment Void

Supreme Court Ruling : Businesses Take Note ,Email Exchanges Can Create a Binding Arbitration Agreement