Tag: Electronic Evidence

Why the Accused Were Freed: Supreme Court Explains Legal Holes in Prosecution’s Murder Conspiracy Case
27Nov By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Why the Accused Were Freed: Supreme Court Explains Legal Holes in Prosecution’s Murder Conspiracy Case

The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's acquittal, emphasizing the prosecution's failure to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence presented, including motive, last seen theory, and recoveries, was found unreliable, inconclusive, and legally inadmissible. The Court reiterated that appellate interference in an acquittal is unwarranted unless the judgment is perverse or based on a misreading of evidence. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from the murder of Shri Suresh Sharma, whose body was discovered on January 23, 2006, with his hands tied and visible signs of strangulation. The prosecution's case was that the respondents, Bhanwar Singh, Hemlata, and Narpat Choudhary, conspired to kill the deceased due to various motives. It was alleged that Hemlata and her husband Na...
Read More
No Retrial Merely to Fill Gaps in Prosecution, Rules Supreme Court in Drug Case
4Nov By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

No Retrial Merely to Fill Gaps in Prosecution, Rules Supreme Court in Drug Case

The Supreme Court held that a retrial is an exceptional remedy not warranted merely to rectify procedural lapses in evidence admission. Electronic evidence complying with Section 65B of the Evidence Act is admissible without a transcript. The non-examination of a Chemical Analyst or non-production of samples is not automatically fatal, as an appellate court can remedy such defects under Section 391 CrPC instead of ordering a retrial. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from a raid conducted by police on a hut based on information that the appellant, Kailas, and another accused were stocking Ganja for sale. Following due procedure, the raiding party, which included panch witnesses and a gazetted officer, searched the hut and recovered 18 plastic packets containing 39 kilograms of Ganja...
Read More
Forced Marriage to Murder: The Shocking Case of Kum. Shubha & the Tragic Crime
4Aug By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Forced Marriage to Murder: The Shocking Case of Kum. Shubha & the Tragic Crime

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of the appellants under Section 302 read with Section 120-B IPC for conspiring to murder the deceased, relying on circumstantial evidence, including Call Detail Records (CDRs) and motive established through witness testimonies. The Court clarified the admissibility of electronic evidence under Section 65-B of the Evidence Act and emphasized that constitutional powers under Article 161 (pardoning power of the Governor) remain exercisable despite statutory remission rules. The judgment reaffirmed the principles of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda for circumstantial evidence while dismissing appeals but allowed the convicts to seek pardon. Facts Of The Case: In December 2003, Kum. Shubha (A-4), a 20-year-old law student, was engaged to B.V. Girish (deceased),...
Read More
CDs as Evidence: Supreme Court Clarifies Rules for Production in CBI Case
11Jun By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

CDs as Evidence: Supreme Court Clarifies Rules for Production in CBI Case

The Supreme Court upheld that additional documents can be produced by the prosecution even after the charge sheet is filed, especially if inadvertently omitted. The Court reiterated that Section 173(5) of the CrPC is directory, not mandatory, and permits the production of documents gathered before or after investigation with court permission. The judgment clarifies that the authenticity of such documents remains an open issue to be proved during trial. Facts Of The Case: An FIR was registered on May 3, 2013, for offences under the IPC and the PC Act. The dispute involves two Compact Discs (CDs). Between January 8, 2013, and May 1, 2013, the Ministry of Home Affairs permitted the interception of telephone calls of several accused and one Manoj Garg. On May 4 and May 10, 2013, two CDs cont...
Read More