DNA Evidence - The Legal Chamber

Betrayal of Trust is Demonic: Supreme Court’s Powerful Stand on Incest & POCSO Act Upholds Life Term for Father Who Raped Minor Daughter

29Aug

By The Legal ChamberNo Comments

Supreme Court

Betrayal of Trust is Demonic: Supreme Court’s Powerful Stand on Incest & POCSO Act Upholds Life Term for Father Who Raped Minor Daughter

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction under POCSO Act Section 6 and IPC Section 506, affirming the statutory presumption of guilt under Section 29. It emphasized that a child victim's credible testimony requires no corroboration and denied bail, highlighting the severity of familial sexual abuse and the imperative for stringent punishment. Facts Of The Case: The case involved the appellant, Bhanei Prasad @ Raju, who was convicted for repeatedly committing aggravated penetrative sexual assault on his own minor daughter. The victim was approximately ten years old at the time of the incidents, which were not isolated but constituted sustained assaults within the family home. The prosecution case was built primarily on the unwavering and credible oral testimony of the victim (PW-3), ...

DNA Evidence & Last Seen Theory : Supreme Court Commutes Death Penalty to Life in Child Rape-Murder Case

The Supreme Court upheld the conviction of the accused under Sections 376, 377, 302 IPC and Section 5/6 POCSO Act for the sexual assault and murder of a minor. However, it commuted the death penalty to life imprisonment, ruling that the case did not meet the "rarest of rare" standard due to insufficient consideration of mitigating circumstances and rehabilitation potential. The Court emphasized the necessity of balancing aggravating and mitigating factors before imposing capital punishment, following precedents like Mohd. Farooq Abdul Gafur and Gudda v. State of M.P., while affirming the reliability of DNA evidence and the last-seen theory in securing conviction. Facts Of The Case: The case involved the brutal sexual assault and murder of a 10-year-old girl in Dehradun, Uttarakhand. On 2...

DNA Mishandling Leads to Acquittal: Supreme Court Criticizes Investigation in Brutal Murder Case

The Supreme Court acquitted the accused in a double murder and rape case, ruling that the prosecution failed to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The Court highlighted critical lapses, including unreliable circumstantial evidence, mishandled DNA samples, an improperly conducted Test Identification Parade, and lack of motive. It emphasized strict adherence to forensic protocols and reaffirmed that circumstantial evidence must form an unbroken chain pointing solely to the accused’s guilt. The judgment underscored the prosecution’s burden to ensure a fair investigation and maintain evidentiary integrity. Facts Of The Case: In May 2011, two young victims—Ezhil Muthalvan (D1) and Kasturi (D2)—were found brutally murdered near Suruli Falls in Tamil Nadu. D1 had left home under the prete...