Tag: Disclosure Statement

A Landmark Ruling on Fair Trials: Supreme Court Issues New Guidelines for Video Conferencing and Witness Confrontation
4Feb By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

A Landmark Ruling on Fair Trials: Supreme Court Issues New Guidelines for Video Conferencing and Witness Confrontation

The Supreme Court of India acquitted the appellant, primarily on the ground that the dock identification of the accused by the sole injured eyewitness, recorded via video conferencing after an inordinate delay of over eight years, was deemed unsafe and unreliable. The Court found the testimony suffered from material improvements and inconsistencies, and the recoveries were not conclusively linked to the crime. Consequently, the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Facts Of The Case: In the intervening night of 2nd/3rd November 2008, five assailants broke into the Delhi residence of Madan Mohan Gulati and his wife, Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18). The intruders assaulted the elderly couple, resulting in Madan Mohan's death and serious injuries to Indra Prabha. The poli...
Read More
Supreme Court Acquits Accused in Murder Case: Recovery of Weapon Alone is Not Proof
4Feb By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Acquits Accused in Murder Case: Recovery of Weapon Alone is Not Proof

The Supreme Court acquitted the appellant, holding that the conviction under Section 302 IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act was unsustainable. The Court ruled that the recovery of a firearm from a place accessible to others, without independent corroboration or proof it was the murder weapon, is insufficient to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Facts Of The Case: The case concerns the murder of Promila on June 12, 2016, in village M.P. Majra, Haryana. The First Information Report (FIR) was registered by her brother, Pradeep (PW-1), alleging that three unidentified men in a car shot her. Five days later, in a supplementary statement, Pradeep named the appellant, Govind, along with Sanoj and Amit, as the perpetrators. During the investigation, a country-made pistol and two live cart...
Read More
Supreme Court Acquits Man in POCSO Death Penalty Case Citing Procedural Flaws
23Dec By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Acquits Man in POCSO Death Penalty Case Citing Procedural Flaws

This Supreme Court judgment sets aside the appellant's conviction and death sentence, holding that the trial was vitiated due to a denial of fair trial rights, including inadequate legal representation and failure to provide documents. The prosecution's circumstantial evidence—last seen, CCTV footage, disclosure statements, and DNA reports—was found unreliable and unproven beyond reasonable doubt. Facts Of The Case: A seven-year-old girl went missing on February 5, 2017, from her residence in Chengalpet, Tamil Nadu, while her parents were out shopping. After an unsuccessful search, a missing persons report was filed. Investigations, including reviewing CCTV footage from a nearby temple, led the police to suspect the appellant, Dashwanth, a neighbour residing in the same building. He was ...
Read More
Supreme Court Explains When It Can’t Be Trusted :Dying Declaration Sole Basis for Conviction?
7Oct By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Explains When It Can’t Be Trusted :Dying Declaration Sole Basis for Conviction?

This Supreme Court judgment underscores the indispensable procedural safeguards for a fair trial, particularly the right to effective legal representation. It reiterates that a conviction based solely on a dying declaration requires the court to be fully satisfied of its voluntariness, truthfulness, and that the deceased was in a fit state of mind. The ruling emphasizes that such a declaration cannot form the basis for conviction if it suffers from grave infirmities, such as the lack of a fitness certification from an identified doctor and the recording officer's failure to note his own satisfaction regarding the declarant's condition. Facts Of The Case: On March 31, 2012, Munish Kumar and his brother Amit were returning to their village by car when they were intercepted by two other veh...
Read More