Tag: Disability Assessment

Can a Court Award More Than You Claimed? Supreme Court Upholds ‘Just Compensation’ in Accident Cases
3Mar By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Can a Court Award More Than You Claimed? Supreme Court Upholds ‘Just Compensation’ in Accident Cases

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal in part, holding that tribunals can award compensation exceeding the claimed amount under the Motor Vehicles Act to ensure just and fair relief. It emphasized adding future prospects to monthly income for calculating loss of earnings due to functional disability. The Court also granted a lump sum for attendant care based on the claimant's age and injuries. Facts Of The Case: On 26.01.2012, the appellant, R. Logeshkumar, aged 21, was riding a motorcycle from Selaiyur to Medavakkam in Chennai. At the Kamarajapuram junction, a jeep owned by the first respondent and insured by the second respondent came from the opposite direction in a rash and negligent manner, without sounding a horn, and collided with his motorcycle. The accident caused grievous injuri...
Read More
Tribunal’s Income Assessment Upheld: Supreme Court Partially Allows Appeal in Injury Claim Case
22Nov By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Tribunal’s Income Assessment Upheld: Supreme Court Partially Allows Appeal in Injury Claim Case

The Supreme Court partially restored the Tribunal's compensation award, upholding the adopted monthly income and modifying attendant charges. It clarified that in the absence of a cross-appeal by the claimant, enhancement beyond the Tribunal's award or addition of future prospects cannot be claimed against the insurer's appeal. Facts Of The Case: On January 5, 2013, the appellant, Ramar, was standing by the side of the road when a rashly and negligently driven lorry hit him. The accident resulted in grievous injuries, leading to the amputation of his right leg from the thigh and a crush injury to his left leg, which paralyzed it. Medical evidence presented before the Tribunal, including the testimony of treating doctors and hospital records, proved the nature of the injuries and as...
Read More
Not Just Salaried: Supreme Court Rules Self-Employed Accident Victims Get Future Income Rise
8Sep By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Not Just Salaried: Supreme Court Rules Self-Employed Accident Victims Get Future Income Rise

The Supreme Court held that self-employed claimants are entitled to future prospects, affirming the principles in Santosh Devi and Pranay Sethi. It further ruled that uncontroverted medical evidence on disability must be accepted in its entirety, and the percentage of disability assessed by the treating doctor cannot be arbitrarily reduced by the Tribunal or High Court without reasoning. Facts Of The Case: On November 19, 2016, at approximately 6:00 a.m., the appellant, Lokesh B, a 38-year-old tailor, was driving his Omni car on the Peenya flyover in Bengaluru. His vehicle collided with a stationary lorry that was allegedly parked in the middle of the flyover without any indicators or reflective warnings. As a result of the collision, Lokesh sustained grievous injuries, including skull f...
Read More
Supreme Court Landmark Ruling: Skilled Worker Gets Higher Disability Compensation
22Jul By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Landmark Ruling: Skilled Worker Gets Higher Disability Compensation

The Supreme Court upheld the claimant's appeal, enhancing compensation for permanent disability from 25% to 35% based on medical evidence, rejecting the Tribunal's unsupported reduction. It affirmed Rs. 6,000/month income for the skilled mason, applying future prospects and multiplier method. The Court emphasized expert medical opinion's primacy in disability assessment and awarded Rs. 7.19 lakh with interest, reinforcing just compensation principles under motor accident claims. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, Suresh Jatav, a skilled mason, suffered severe injuries in a motor vehicle accident on 12.08.2002 when a rashly driven bus collided with his auto-rickshaw. He sustained a compound fracture in his right fibula, requiring surgical intervention and hospitalization for six days, as w...
Read More