constitutional remedy - The Legal Chamber

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies that validly terminated contracts do not constitute "assets" of a corporate debtor under the IBC, and its moratorium does not revive extinguished rights. It reaffirms that NCLT cannot interfere with terminations based on pre-existing, non-insolvency-related defaults. Furthermore, High Courts retain constitutional jurisdiction to direct statutory authorities, even during moratorium. Facts Of The Case: The dispute originated from a 2005 Development Agreement between Kher Nagar Sukhsadan Co-operative Housing Society and developer AA Estates for redevelopment of a dilapidated Mumbai building declared dangerous under municipal laws. The agreement required completion within 24 months, but the developer failed to meet this timeline. A Supple...

The Supreme Court held that the appellants' right to provincialisation had crystallised under the 2011 Act. Despite favourable findings, the High Court erred in not granting mandamus relief. The Court modified the impugned judgment, ruling that a Writ Court has inherent power under Article 226 to mould relief and grant consequential mandamus to remedy injustice, which it duly issued. Facts Of The Case: The case originated from a batch of appeals before the Supreme Court, filed by a large group of Music Teachers employed in various provincialised schools in Assam. Their grievance stemmed from the State of Assam's failure to formally provincialise their services under the Assam Venture Educational Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011. The appellants' eligibility had been ...

Tag: constitutional remedy

Supreme Court Orders Assam to Provincialise Services of Music Teachers