Tag: Commercial Litigation

Arbitration Award Final: Supreme Court Dismisses MMTC’s Post-Decree Objections
17Jan By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Arbitration Award Final: Supreme Court Dismisses MMTC’s Post-Decree Objections

This Supreme Court judgment reaffirms that objections to the execution of an arbitral award under Section 47 of the CPC are maintainable only within a very narrow compass, limited to grounds of jurisdictional infirmity or voidness. The Court emphasized that allegations of fraud or breach of fiduciary duty by a party’s own officers, raised after the award has attained finality, do not constitute such grounds unless they render the award a nullity. The business judgment rule protects decisions that fall within a range of reasonableness. Facts Of The Case: The dispute arose from a Long Term Agreement (LTA) dated 07.03.2007 between MMTC Limited and Anglo American Metallurgical Coal Pvt. Limited for the supply of coking coal. The agreement included an option for MMTC to extend the con...
Read More
Landmark Ruling Protects IP Owners: Supreme Court Says Continuous Infringement Creates Inherent Urgency
4Jan By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Landmark Ruling Protects IP Owners: Supreme Court Says Continuous Infringement Creates Inherent Urgency

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies that under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, a suit alleging continuing infringement of intellectual property rights inherently contemplates urgent interim relief. The Court held that mere delay in filing the suit does not negate urgency, as each ongoing act of infringement causes immediate and irreparable harm, and public interest in preventing market deception also factors into the assessment. Facts Of The Case: The appellant, a Danish company named Novenco Building and Industry A/S, held patents and design registrations in India for its industrial fans sold under the brand ‘Novenco ZerAx’. It had entered into a dealership agreement with respondent No. 1, Xero Energy Engineering Solutions Pvt. Ltd., in 2017. The appellant later discov...
Read More
Death of a Partner Doesn’t End Business: Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Reconstituted Firm
22Jul By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

Death of a Partner Doesn’t End Business: Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Reconstituted Firm

The Supreme Court upheld the Calcutta High Court’s decision, ruling that a partnership firm does not automatically dissolve upon a partner’s death if the partnership deed permits continuation with surviving partners. The Court held that Indian Oil Corporation (IOCL) could not arbitrarily stop kerosene supply without terminating the dealership agreement. It clarified that reconstitution of the firm does not require all legal heirs to join, emphasizing IOCL’s obligation to act fairly as a state instrumentality. The judgment reinforced that contractual terms and partnership deeds override rigid policy guidelines in commercial disputes. Facts Of The Case: The case involved a dispute between Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) and M/s Shree Niwas Ramgopal, a partnership firm operating as a ...
Read More
“Can Courts Reject a Plaint for Skipping Mediation? :Supreme Court’s Strict Rule for Commercial Cases”
22May By The Legal ChamberNo Comments
Supreme Court

“Can Courts Reject a Plaint for Skipping Mediation? :Supreme Court’s Strict Rule for Commercial Cases”

The Supreme Court upheld the mandatory nature of Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, requiring pre-institution mediation for commercial suits unless urgent interim relief is sought. However, it clarified that non-compliance before August 20, 2022 (the date of its earlier ruling in Patil Automation) does not warrant plaint rejection—instead, courts may refer parties to mediation while keeping suits in abeyance. The judgment harmonizes procedural rigor with practical enforcement, ensuring mediation’s role in reducing litigation backlog without unduly penalizing past filings. Facts Of The Case: The case arose from a money suit filed by the Union of India against M/s Dhanbad Fuels Pvt. Ltd. in the Commercial Court, Alipore, seeking recovery of ₹8.73 crores as differential freight...
Read More