acquittal by Supreme Court - The Legal Chamber

The Supreme Court acquitted the accused, ruling the prosecution failed to establish a complete chain of circumstantial evidence. Key scientific evidence, including DNA reports, was deemed inadmissible due to an unproven chain of custody and procedural flaws. The Court emphasized that suspicion, however strong, cannot substitute for proof beyond reasonable doubt. Facts Of The Case: On the evening of September 4, 2012, a 12-year-old girl left her home to answer the call of nature and did not return. Her parents initiated a search throughout the night. The next morning, her denuded body was discovered in a paddy field belonging to Harikrishna Sharma. Her personal belongings, including her slippers, water canister, and underwear, were found scattered in an adjacent field cultivated by the ac...

The Supreme Court acquitted the appellant, granting the benefit of doubt. The conviction was overturned due to material inconsistencies in the prosecution's case, including an unexplained timeline of death, unrebutted defence evidence of family enmity, and a lack of medical corroboration for the alleged weapon and dying declaration. Facts Of The Case: Based on the altercation, the appellant and her husband were accused of fatally beating the deceased with sticks near a temple later that night. The prosecution's case, supported by eyewitnesses including the deceased's father (PW-7), was that the attack was retaliation for the afternoon dispute. The victim was allegedly carried home unconscious and died minutes later, with a First Information Report (FIR) lodged around 9:00 PM. How...

Tag: acquittal by Supreme Court

Beyond Reasonable Doubt: Supreme Court Frees Men, Citing Gaps in Circumstantial Case

How Unexplained Injuries and a Family Dispute Led to an Acquittal by the Supreme Court